some things i do like
It’s never much fun to write a negative review of something — not unless you’re ready to just dismiss the thing on its face. If you lack that useful skill, writing a negative review represents the opposite of fun: it represents sitting down and listening, closely, over and over, to music you’re not really enjoying, trying to understand as much as you can about it, trying to find a way to like it, trying to find the ways other people might like it, hoping you’ll at least work up enough Stockholm Syndrome to put yourself on its side. And it represents coming away from all that without having found many reasons to call the experience rewarding, which usually feels more like a failure than anything else.
All that comes by way of telling you that I reviewed Interpol’s new album for Pitchfork, and thought the record was, simply put, kind of a drag. Each time I listened through it, the first half would make me think that assessment was unfair, but by the time I got to the end I’d be right back where I started: drag city, via Matador. That’s like an indie-rock Uncle Joke, if you missed it.
So now, before I get around to explaining how I felt about Franzen’s book, I feel a need to do some penance by listing some things I do like:
Being married. I don’t think I ever mentioned on here that I got married last month, which is cool, because now I can make Uncle Jokes (these are different from Dad Jokes) safe in the knowledge that I’m now actually someone’s weird uncle.
The Private Lives of Trees, by Alejandro Zambra. He’s a Chilean writer, and seems to have gotten a lot of U.S. press because he’s easy to package as the opposite of Bolano — someone writing tiny, airy novels instead of sprawling, bloody ones. Alternately: the other night we were having dinner with a friend of my wife’s from Argentina, and she said Chileans have a lot of good writers, but they’re also good at marketing themselves — writers, wine, whatever. (This made me happy I hadn’t ordered the Chilean sea bass, originally known as “Patagonian toothfish.”) Regardless: I believe this is Zambra’s second book, and it was the first, Bonsai, which made more of a splash, though I haven’t found a copy yet. Reading something short and spare in translation is always odd — all this time has been put into small choices that might get lost — but something about this book got me. It read, to me, strangely like good Kundera, the bits where he pays this kind of abstracted attention to the small bits of lives, where every detail feels like a condensed diagrammatic example illustrating a larger question.
White Collar, which pretends to be a TV show on USA but is basically a menswear showcase with a general fetish for finely made things. It’s about an extremely handsome and rakish art thief/con man who winds up working with the FBI to solve crimes similar to the ones he committed, and has to wear really, really nice clothes in order to look better than his FBI partner, who is supposed to seem more drab but wears pretty decent suits himself, and is reassuringly manly in a sort of middle-aged Harrison Ford kind of way. (Sometimes the handsome thief Goes Too Far by involving a bad hat or trying something over-the-top with his ties or trouser/jacket pairings.) I’d estimate that about 40% of my viewings of this show are accompanied by idly shopping for clothes online.
William Brittelle’s Television Landscape. This album comes from a place I find alternately fascinating and confusing, which is the borderland some people call “alt-classical” or “indie-classical.” Neither is a great term, I don’t think. But what it is, a lot of the time, is properly trained composers and musicians — conservatory-type folks, new-music folks — trying things that fall outside genres, often tinkering with pop modes. In New York there’s a scene in this territory. My experience with it is limited; it mostly comes from the label New Amsterdam and a friend who covers such things. But I think that often, the results work a lot like “progressive” indie or electronic music, offering interesting new visions of how pop stuff might sound … and then sometimes they’re totally mystifying to me, like really bland studious constipated versions of pop — and then I’ll ask a better-trained person what’s supposed to be good about it, and maybe she’ll say “ah well did you notice that microtonal bit and the playful harmonic references to Debussy,” and I will say, umm, no, I am not that bright. So some of this stuff exists for the audience of classical/new-music people, and is talking to them in a way I don’t have access to. But William Brittelle’s Television Landscape is not! It’s an effort to make a big squishy proggy soft-rock album, and it has a relaxed, breezy, stonery vibe that reminds me of late-90s stuff like Chicago post-rock (Jim O’Rourke, Sea & Cake) and Mercury Rev’s See You on the Other Side, and some of the songs are shot through with wonderfully nerdy guitar solos that I like to imagine, if you notated them on paper, would wind up making the shapes of unicorns in leather jackets.
Finally reading Tom McCarthy’s Remainder, just in time to watch people have vastly different reactions to his new book, C. (Or maybe it’s just Kakutani leading the less-satisfied voices.)
The upgraded speed of change-sorting machines at the nearest bank that has them. Seriously, because these things are LOUD and often set up right near the tellers, and back when I was broke a lot I would always feel really bad about spending 15 minutes clanking and pouring and jingling, trying to convert all the loose change in my apartment into grocery money for a few weeks. I haven’t been super-broke in a long while, which means my excess change had been piling up like nobody’s business, so when I headed to the bank this morning with almost too much change to even carry down the street, I was a little anxious about the whole thing. But apparently they have souped those things up, and the one I was using got through an epic, almost embarrassing amount of loose change with alacrity. Except for the part where one of the bags filled up and I had to call an employee over to change it out.
-
replica---watches liked this
-
zapp645 reblogged this from agrammar and added:
I recently had the weird experience of having to engage with this exact issue. I posted some disparaging comments about...
-
mlarson liked this
-
beckylang said:
i don’t mind writing negative reviews. i see it as a matter of digging into the math of the thing - where did the equation go wrong? what i hate is reviewing something with a cult following from an outside perspective. then you have to get the spirit
-
wehavethingstolookforwardto liked this
-
desnoise liked this
-
grantimatter liked this
-
britticisms liked this
-
67seven52 liked this
-
epistrophy liked this
-
jakec liked this
-
markrichardson liked this
-
howtolistentomusic liked this
-
ontheheap liked this
-
monicalong liked this
-
heck liked this
-
cureforbedbugs reblogged this from tomewing and added:
This reminds me of a nice Frank Kogan quote:...(Sorry I can’t find the original source...
-
grandweerachael liked this
-
raptoravatar liked this
-
berezina liked this
-
perpetua said:
…and here we have Alex explaining why he is such a bad critic!
-
gabbytron liked this
-
absolutefucker liked this
-
agrammar reblogged this from alexmacpherson and added:
Yup — that’s exactly why I called it a “useful skill” that I’ve turned out not to have! Dismissing things on their face...
-
versestheoctopus liked this
-
thirtydollarproject liked this
-
tomewing reblogged this from alexmacpherson and added:
saying on Twitter...other day how it’s really...when you...
-
alexmacpherson reblogged this from agrammar and added:
JUST thinking today...people - particularly critics - who
-
hndrk liked this
-
therichgirlsareweeping said:
Oh, and! Felicitaitons!
-
therichgirlsareweeping liked this
-
anythingcouldhappen said:
Ah jeez Nitsuh, congrats on getting married! I actually tried to watch White Collar on OnDemand last night. Couldn’t get through more than 5 minutes. But then I wasn’t watching for the clothes either.
-
pitchforkreviewsreviews liked this
-
wrestlingentropy liked this
-
lalitree liked this
-
mina-ann-lee liked this
-
maura liked this
-
hardandhard liked this
-
bisutun liked this
-
clio-jlh reblogged this from agrammar and added:
Lately—probably since...started—I’ve been feeling some cultural claustrophobia. This...
-
douglasmartini said:
Your Interpol review is the best Pitchfork review I’ve read in quite some time. Maybe even years.
-
douglasmartini liked this
-
bwall05 said:
Congrats on getting married, by the way!
-
karion liked this
-
celebraterickysargulesh said:
Did you LIKE ‘Remainder,’ or did you just like _finally reading_ ‘Remainder?? Inquiring minds.
-
bwall05 liked this
-
bmichael said:
aww shit. are you done with franzens new novel? it’s like so far it’s like tao lin trying to write tolstoy or variations on a shallow presentation of something deep. but it’s not unpleasant exactly for me (as of p 240)
-
bmichael liked this
-
clio-jlh liked this
- Show more notes