a grammar

The Big Music

tomewing:

New Poptimist! About Coldplay, epic rock, religion, half-remembered bits from my English A-Level, etc etc.

Another great Poptimist column, as happens about once a month!

On This Is the Sea, Mike Scott seemed to pull it back to its religious meaning, as an expression of your communion with a higher force. Not God, though: truth, meaningfulness, music itself. The Big Music rewrote rock as a kind of secular gospel music: meta-gospel, where the object of worship is all about how high the music you’re listening to dreams of being.

A while back, I was thinking/writing about something I think might be related — a habit, among indie bands, of shooting for similar feelings. Only the indie bands do it in a way that’s, well, indier: It’s more about drum-banging mysticism, making songs that feel ritualistic, maybe even “pagan.” It never crossed my mind that the urge to Epic Pop-Rock is essentially the same — looking for the sensation of transcendence and uplift and religious transport without needing such a fixed belief on the other end.

Cite Arrow reblogged from tomewing
32 notes | # | Oct 28, 2011
  1. hand-made-jewellery liked this
  2. download-muzica liked this
  3. download-muzica reblogged this from tomewing
  4. kittentroops reblogged this from semipoplife
  5. o-song liked this
  6. jrichmanesq said: animal collective as hipster-Coldplay? i like it!
  7. jrichmanesq liked this
  8. semipoplife reblogged this from agrammar
  9. batteryinyourleg reblogged this from tomewing
  10. thevidsarealright liked this
  11. estamosaqui liked this
  12. bmichael liked this
  13. pgwp reblogged this from agrammar and added:
    Really loved Tom’s column this month. The only offnote I detected was in this paragraph toward the end:
  14. tumblingforth liked this
  15. likeapairofbottlerockets liked this
  16. shorterexcerpts liked this
  17. backleftlitz liked this
  18. katherinestasaph liked this
  19. therichgirlsareweeping liked this
  20. softcommunication liked this
  21. agrammar reblogged this from tomewing and added:
    Another great Poptimist column, as happens about once a month!...A while back, I was...
  22. davebloom liked this
  23. katherinestasaph reblogged this from tomewing and added:
    This is fantastic, as usual — there’s something more to be said about...rock where the...
  24. marathonpacks liked this
  25. dalatu liked this
  26. numaparagemdo28 liked this
  27. desnoise liked this
  28. popcornnoises reblogged this from tomewing and added:
    The notion of rock ‘n roll as secularized gospel music goes back to its very roots (Elvis learning to sing in church,...
  29. hndrk liked this
  30. tomewing posted this

About

- Nitsuh Abebe
- NYC
- grammarlog (at) gmail
- feel free to use the ASK page
- "it might be too 'high level' for me, like writing that belongs in a book or magazine -- not on the internet." -- carles

SELECTED READING:
- "Why We Fight" columns
- The Decade in Indie
- Making Plans for Daniel
- Malachi Ritscher: 1954-2006

Search

More

  • Home
  • Archives
  • Subscribe

Following

  • Clam Bistro
  • Fluxtumblr
  • Tiny Blog in a Heavy Metal Landscape
  • katherine st asaph
  • Blogelstein!
  • Champagne Candy
  • Tyler Coates
  • B Michael Tumblr
  • like a pair of bottle rockets
  • Boatzone 3
  • Tumblr Staff
  • Mrs Tsk *
  • 92nd Street Y
  • naming blogs is easy
  • think locally act globally
  • Growling at the Moon
  • whitneymcn on tumblr
  • Yes
  • Salomé G.
  • a l'allure garconniere
  • Des Noise
  • Screw Rock 'n' Roll
  • Blue Lines Revisited
  • Falling and Laughing
  • Natasha VC
  • Hardcore for Nerds
  • Frank Kogan
  • YOU MIGHT FIND YOURSELF
  • immune to mookies
  • Exist Yesterday.
  • marathonpacks
  • UNBORN WHISKEY
  • Michelle Dean
  • Archipel-a-gogo!
  • back left litz
  • NO COAST OF NEBRASKA
  • Mark Richardson
  • Tower of Sleep
  • Popcorn Noises
  • Celebrate Ricky Sargulesh!
  • Split Infinitives
  • Things, Stuff
  • Sarah Zhang
  • The New Yorker
  • RMXBB
  • So Many Shrimp
  • American Aquarium Drinker
  • This Talking Is Only Bravado
  • Budget Fashionistas
  • no trivia
  • winesburg, ohio
  • BRITTICISMS
  • One Week // One Band
  • i don't know, man
  • $30 Project
  • reach, grasp, taste
  • The New Inquiry
  • Taoist Drunk
  • nehru jackets
  • durga polashi
  • Danger Den
  • casuistry
  • Online Notebook
  • Front of Book: Media, Publishing, and Long-form
  • Pitchfork
  • Every Great Song Ever
  • the notes
  • hate the future
  • Problem World
  • shield your eyes
  • The Feature
  • The Electric Typewriter
  • Carpentrix
  • Reading Markson Reading
  • Something Changed.
  • Fabulous Debris
  • rachael maddux
  • irulan’s other orrery
  • jawnita
  • this is lobster.
  • Tumblin' Erb
  • Hannahmight
  • Amy Rebecca Klein
  • The Towering Irrelevance
  • Middle Savagery (lite)
  • Tumbling Entropy
  • Born Under Punches
  • a portrait of the artist as a young man
  • laughin mane
  • Places We Used To Go: A BLOG ABOUT AMERICA!
  • A Well Respected Tumblr
  • Cr4Bdbgs
  • Just North of Something Important
  • McNally Jackson Bookmongers
  • Jamieson Cox
  • TRMW
  • Second Balcony
  • THE PAREENINGTON POST
  • Joe Coscarelli
  • songs you taught me
  • Cradle to the Grave
  • Hey Ashlie
  • The Dische Reaction
  • the rich girls are weeping
  • 67seven52
  • rebecca LANDO
  • Tae Won Yu
  • jeremy paul gordon
  • ー_ー
  • pop/culture
  • The Doree Chronicles
  • Lianablog
  • This Is
  • Wishful Thinking
  • emmy blotnick
  • Get That L@@k!
  • anything could happen
  • thinlinednotepaper
  • soft communication
  • O, Song! Daily Links
  • Speaking in Tongues
  • Diana Kimball
  • Lindsay Robertson
  • GRAPE POP
  • LEX IS MORE
  • What the hell, summer spell.
  • Alex Balk
  • Extraface Marks
  • winged and finned
  • get up stand up
  • SlushPile Hell
  • Alex Whines
  • The FoxLot
  • I imagine.
  • Dan Harmon Poops
  • Regina Cannot Explain It All
  • Absurdist Media
  • on...
  • Teenage Art
  • Useful Noise
  • Rachel Profiling
  • Après Ski Instructor
  • Sadybusiness
  • realniggatumblr
  • i mean, the end begins
  • up up up
  • firmuhment
  • Leon Crawl
  • Studio Seventeen Tumblr
  • like tigers on vaseline
  • Let Us Read and Let Us Dance
  • TAN
  • IWDRM
  • YESTERDAY! TODAY! FIVE MINUTES AGO! NOW!
  • TongueLash
  • fuckyeahnoiserock
  • Deface Value
  • Noreen Malone
  • LOS ANGELES REVIEW OF BOOKS
  • Shut Up Lefsetz
  • vortex dot net dot en zed
  • PORN SODA
  • ¿Quien maneja mi barca?
  • Fighting crime in the streets together
  • The Ecuador Three
  • BENEFITS OF A CLASSICAL EDUCATION
  • Tumbl Tumbl
  • Molly Lambert
  • timocratic youth
  • Oversets
  • Cosby Show Caps
  • Selvedge
  • SURVIVAL THEMES
  • nine times the same
  • 1000 Times Yes
  • fluffynotes
  • It's Like You Know...
  • Lit Folks are Hip
  • Hark, a Vagrant (RSS Feed)
  • Duchess Leo
  • It Took Seconds
  • An Infinite Number of Monkeys
  • everything is green
  • PCFC THTR
  • will the night
  • Chain of Knives
  • ATALANTA, the Building
  • 2/3 of a Snowman
  • Scattered Speculations
  • Live Wrong and Prosper
  • Icy On Purpose
  • Things That Were or Are Now on Fire (in New York)
  • TMOLSGPEH
  • Ryan Catbird's Tumblr
  • My Year Of Everything
  • Iconography
  • Keith Gessen Blog
  • False Nine
  • That's What She Said.
  • Only Connect
  • Untitled

MoKoyfman Theme by Bill Israel Tumblr powered CC licensed